The 8 BEST Cheap Hotels that Have Great Ratings and Reviews in Key West 2026 (from $122/night)

Delivers budget-friendly luxury with a refreshing outdoor pool in the heart of Key West. After a day exploring vibrant Duval Street or soaking up the sun, what could be better than diving into a sparkling pool at Hilton Garden Inn Key West? The welcoming atmosphere here invites you to unwind, while the fitness center keeps you active and energized. With unbeatable rates and a 7.8-star rating, this hotel stands out as a top choice for savvy travelers seeking quality without breaking the bank. Book your stay now and experience the charm of Key West at a price that lets you enjoy more adventures.

Delivers an unbeatable combination of relaxation and value at an outdoor pool in the heart of Key West. The outdoor pool invites you to soak in the sun, surrounded by comfortable lounging chairs that embody the quintessential vacation vibe. With a free shuttle whisking you to the vibrant Old Town, you can easily dive into the energetic spirit of Key West. Plus, the friendly, 24-hour front desk ensures every need is met, allowing you to focus on creating unforgettable memories. Don't miss out on this great deal, book your stay at Blue Flamingo Resort and start your adventure today.

Brings the charm of Key West with an inviting outdoor pool and easy access to local attractions. Relax in the refreshing outdoor pool where every dip feels like a mini-vacation. Pair that with tropical drinks from the Tiki bar, and you have a recipe for unwinding after a day of exploring. A convenient shuttle service makes wandering through the vibrant streets of Old Town a breeze, ensuring you don't miss a moment of the island's unique spirit. With a stellar rating of 8.6, this hotel invites you to experience Key West without putting a dent in your wallet. Book your stay now and dive into the adventure waiting for you.

Delivers spacious rooms and easy access to Key West's charm without breaking the bank. Step into a world where comfort meets affordability, as each room greets you with modern touches like flat-screen TVs and cozy sofa beds. The free shuttle service opens up the vibrant streets of Key West, making every dining spot and beach within reach. Unwind by the outdoor pool after a day of exploration, or savor a meal at the on-site restaurant, where local flavors await. Don’t miss your chance to experience this gem, book your stay today and dive into the unforgettable atmosphere of Key West.

Features an ocean view heated pool that transforms relaxation into a daily ritual. Imagine sipping a cool drink at the poolside while the sun warms your skin and the ocean sparkles in the distance. Each comfortable non-smoking room comes with a balcony, inviting you to unwind with a view that feels like a luxury getaway, all at a budget-friendly price. Dining at the poolside restaurant adds to the experience, turning meals into moments as you soak in the vibrant atmosphere of Key West. Don’t wait to secure this gem; your unforgettable stay is just a click away.

Boasts spacious accommodations and private balconies in the heart of Key West for under $200 a night. At The Marker Key West Harbor Resort, you can enjoy luxurious comfort without breaking the bank. Each of the 96 air-conditioned rooms features private balconies or patios, inviting you to unwind in your own slice of paradise. With three outdoor swimming pools and a delightful poolside restaurant, relaxation is just steps away from your door. This remarkable haven is waiting for you, so secure your stay today and immerse yourself in the charm of Key West.

Delivers an unforgettable Key West experience with beachfront dining and three inviting outdoor pools. Imagine savoring delicious American cuisine while gazing at the endless ocean, the waves lapping at the shore just steps away. Dive into one of the three outdoor pools, where relaxation takes on a whole new meaning under the Florida sun. With a star rating of 8.8, this haven caters to those seeking both tranquility and adventure in a vibrant locale. Don't wait to secure your slice of paradise, book now and immerse yourself in the beauty of Key West.

Delivers a prime location and refreshing escapes at an unbeatable price in Key West. Just a few blocks from the historic harbor, Fitch Lodge positions you perfectly for immersing yourself in the vibrant culture of Key West. Imagine strolling to nearby museums and soaking up the island's rich history before retreating to the inviting outdoor pool for a refreshing dip. This is the sanctuary for budget-conscious travelers seeking authentic experiences without breaking the bank. Don't miss your chance to secure a slice of paradise at Fitch Lodge, book your stay now and embrace the adventure.